Black House (2007)

"Black House" is a wildly uneven but nevertheless very entertaining horror/thriller from South Korea. The plot doesn't contain a single element you haven't seen at least three dozen of times before, and it seems as if director Terra Shin couldn't decide what type of movie he wanted to deliver, but at least it guarantees a good 100 minutes of suspense and (speaking for my girlfriend) a few horrible sleepless nights. The title "Black House" suggests a supernatural haunted house thriller, but the titular residential building is actually of no relevance to the plot whatsoever… It opens as an ambitious psychological thriller about a young insurance agent, naturally struggling with some unprocessed childhood traumas, who tries to prove that one of his clients deliberately murdered his young stepson in order to claim the insurance money. The story, albeit highly unoriginal, is overall compelling and intense. The film features several downright creepy moments (like an answering machine full of silent recordings) as well as horrendous genre clichés (like decapitated pet dogs). But then, suddenly, the plot takes a complete U-turn and atmosphere as well as tone and direction alters entirely. Through some revelations and discoveries, our insurance agent all of a sudden finds himself relentlessly pursued by a totally insane and maniacal female! The whole insurance fraud scheme, carefully built up until then, doesn't matter anymore and "Black House" turns into a derivative slasher/torture porn flick with sadist murder sequences and an indestructible killer. Oh well, fine by me also, it just requires a fast and rather unanticipated switch of mindset. The acting performances are decent, the make-up effects suitably vile and the set-pieces nicely sinister. South Korea arguably brings forward the best horror/thriller productions of the entire Asian continent, with for example the works of Jee-Woon Kim ("A Tale of Two Sisters", "I Saw the Devil") and Chan-wook Park ("Oldboy", "Lady Vengeance"). "Black House" doesn't belong to the elite, of course, but it's definitely worth tracking down.

Jean Juno, a former banker, starts a new job working as an insurance salesman, immediately finding himself in a bit of a quandary, a client, demanding payment on the loss of his child, could have murdered his own step-son. Juno, not accepting that this little boy actually committed suicide, believing he was murdered, will attempt to prove his death was in fact a homicide. Juno is haunted by the suicide of his brother(a victim of bullies)and this has shaped him as an adult.In regards to cold blooded female psychopaths, Shin Yi-Hwa reminded me of Béatrice Dalle from À l'intérieur and Asami Yamazaki(Eihi Shiina)of Takashi Miike's Ôdishon. She has these black soulless eyes reminiscent to Michael Meyers, there's a void where humanity should be present yet isn't. Yi-Hwa moves in a deliberate but determined manner, a crook in her walk due to a handicapped foot which bends inward. Director Terra Shin often points his camera at Yi-Hwa's feet, establishing her presence in a room approaching her quarry with evil intent. The hero of this movie Jean Juno(Jeong-min Hwang)wants desperately to believe that Yi-Hwa is human, that she has emotions, can feel something. What we see, though, is anything but. To manipulate her unstable (third) husband to chop of his arms for insurance money(and to sew a victim's eyes shut, pulling another with a chain in front of a moving train), it's hard to accept that Yi-Hwa is human at all. BLACK HOUSE is definitely macabre in the grandest sense as Jean Juno's insurance salesman/investigator questions whether or not Yi-Hwa's son actually committed suicide or was hung by his step-father, Park Choong-Bae(Shin-il Kang)for a 30 million dollar policy taken out only recently on the entire family. Choong-Bae was heavily in debt due to a gambling habit, only a sheet metal worker unemployed yet somehow still making the payments on the policy. Juno is a direct opposite of Yi-Hwa, his heart is pure and only wants justice for the dead boy he found hung in Choong-Bae's home. At the onset, Juno thought Yi-Hwa was in danger, but as he crusades in behalf of the fallen child, a startling discovery awakens him to the truth..it's not Choong-Bae who is the mastermind behind gaining moneys from insurance policies, but Yi-Hwa. Warning Juno to pay up and butt out, Yi-Hwa is only concerned with the money and will kill anyone who stands in her way. Labeling Yi-Hwa as dedicated would be an understatement. Juno also inadvertently brings his beloved girlfriend, a hospital doc, Mina(Seao-hyeong Kim)into the cross-hairs of Yi-Hwa's mania. Yi-Hwa will use Mina to draw Juno into her lair, a veritable slaughterhouse where multiple victims(including an insurance investigator from Juno's company whose upper torso is hanging from hooks, eyes and mouth sown shut)and their body parts are stored. I'm amused at how the butcher knives in horror movies nowadays resemble machetes, they're so long and gigantic, quite imposing especially when you have someone as intimidating as Yi-Hwa pressing her way towards you with only one goal in mind, burying it into her prey's body. Juno pays a price for his courage, taking his share of lumps(more like stabs)because of this pursuit to see that Yi-Hwa is stopped. Fans of horror movies about psychotics should enjoy this one. There's a character whose role is small but important as it pertains to Yi-Hwa's downfall, a student working on a thesis about psychopaths who provides Juno some information on his subject, this research costing him his life. I imagine that anyone who sees BLACK HOUSE will be hard pressed to forget Seon Yu's role as Yi-Hwa; she definitely leaves a lump in the throat, particularly at the end where she toys with her bleeding eye socket(Juno punctures it with a house key!)seemingly unable to feel any pain whatsoever.

By the title of my review, you might think I would chide films for imitating Hollywood out of some sort of reverence for the latter, but that couldn't be farther from the truth as Black House's imitation is its ultimate downfall. Being a fan of Korean cinema and having seen the original film (Kuroi Ie from Japan), I was disappointed to find that director Shin Terra basically removed the deeper aspects of psychology from the story and chose instead to focus on developing the plot along in the most basic of manners.At the beginning of the film, insurance agent Jun-oh is drawn into a complex web of death, dismemberment, and deceit as he suspects the apparent suicide of a client's son was not suicide at all. What would seem like simple insurance fraud grows into something much more sinister as Jun-oh encounters a true psychopath. But where the film goes wrong is in focusing on Jun-oh and his generic, last-minute back story rather than on the nature of a psychopath. Let's face it, Jun-oh the character is not interesting in the least. He goes through no changes throughout the film and his immovable belief in humanity at the end of the film is all the more laughable and ridiculous after the graphic horrors he witnesses. Sure, as you say, the killer is just like you. They just like to rip the heads off of dogs and cut people into little pieces. But they're just like you. Where Kuroi Ie goes right in this aspect is first depicting the psychopath from the very beginning of the film. You know who you're dealing with, so the whole movie carries a tense atmosphere. Black House, on the other hand, chooses to go the red herring route with an oh-so-obvious red herring and oh-so-obvious culprit. The ultimate revelation for Jun-oh is neither surprising nor shocking. Kuroi Ie scores here in a second manner by depicting the psychopath with a true disconnect, a real sense of going through life without a care, rather than as a bland and boring caricature TRYING to act like a psychopath.In the end, Black House tries to differentiate itself from the stale output of vengeful ghost films, but it falls instead into the generic thriller camp. Too stupid to be scary, and too boring to be intelligent. Couple all that with a cheesy, tacked-on ending about the cycle of violence and you've got yourself the worst kind of film - one that thinks its being artsy.

Insurance agent, Jun-oh (jeong-min Hwang) goes to a house to talk to an insurance client, where he finds the hanging body of the client's son dead of an apparent suicide. But he soon feels that the young lad didn't kill himself, but was killed to get at a sizable insurance payout. When no one else seems to believe him or even care, Jun decides to get to the truth by himself by digging into the past of the troubled family.Let it be noted that I have yet to see "Kuroi ie" the 1999 Japanese adaptation of the same Yûsuke Kishi novel that this film was also based on, so I can't offer up any comparisons. That being said, I found the South Korean version of the story to be captivating enough to keep my attention throughout and marginally well acted. The film plays it's horror out mostly psychologically until it's last 40 minutes when the film goes all out Slasher and the gore becomes much more visceral. I enjoyed and recommend it.My grade: B- Region 1 DVD Extras: A 21 minute Making of; Production design featurette (7 minute); and 10 deleted scenes