La Petite Jérusalem (2005)

This film has probably already made the circuit of the Jewish film festivals and will continue to be screened in Jewish series in cinemateques, as it deals with the French Jewish environment and the tensions between the Jewish traditional life and the modern world. However, what may be a relatively new theme in the French cinema is already beaten track in the Israeli films. A few excellent films coming from Israel have dealt with similar subjects in the last few years. It is amusing to a certain extent to see as the relatively young Israeli cinema matures, the French cinema with its long tradition seems to repeat the mistakes of the older Israeli cinema - trying to tell too much in one movie, schematic and stereotype representation of the characters, temptation of folklorist approach when dealing with the Jewish customs, and too little characters development.To its merit I must mention that La Petite Jerusalem is quite accurate in rendering Jewish life, and that acting has quality, especially the actresses playing the two sisters whose story is in the center of the movie are attractive and sensible. The tension between the spiritual Jewish life and the temptation of sexuality deeply felt by the two sisters (one married and one not) and up to a certain extent the relationship between the younger sister and the Arab Muslim co-worker are depicted in a direct and quite effective style. It is the mix of too many parallel stories that are insufficiently developed and get too fast and easy solutions that gives the impression of superficiality. Then the relationship with the Arab boyfriend is too quickly expedited, and he depiction of the boy's family is surprisingly stereotype for a French film. The stories of the two sisters get unsatisfying solutions, one inconclusive, the other one too simplistic. Overall 'La Petite Jerusalem' is a sincere but not successful tentative in a genre that has produced better films.

The Tunisian-French Laura (Fanny Valette) is a young woman that lives with her Orthodox Jewish family in the Jewish community in the suburbs of Paris. Her mother is a widow that left Tunisia; her sister Mathilde (Elsa Zylberstein) is having troubles in her marriage because she repressed her sexual desire based on her misunderstandings of the principles of her religion. Laura is an open minded student of philosophy and works cleaning a school in the nightshift. While Laura feels a strong passion and desire for her Muslin Algerian colleague, her sister finds that her husband had an affair with a woman and looks for an adviser that helps her to interpret the true meaning of love and the duties of a married woman."La Petite Jerusalem" is a sensitive film about religion, intolerance, philosophy and repressed desire. The story exposes how religion may affect relationships through the dilemma of two sisters raised a conservative community. The older one misunderstands and is confused about the limits of intimacy of a couple, and the younger feels how prejudice and intolerance may affect relationships even of those that are less religious or more open-minded. The magnificent performances are very realistic and Fanny Valette is an extremely beautiful woman. My vote is seven.Title (Brazil): "A Pequena Jerusalém" ("The Little Jerusalem")

I thought the movie was well done from the beginning. We center on Laura, from the opening scene breaking from the rest of the crowd to pray on her own beside the river. This could be a slight hint at the direction her faith might be taking. Separate, deep concentration, solitary. etc.. WE learn that she has decided to cast away her premonitions of sensual desires as controlling and things best kept at bay. Until we are introduced to the calm and mysterious Djamel. A scene in the locker room. when he covers her slightly bare arm, was as sensual as any sex scene any movie could produce. We see that his intentions are genuine and not harmful. Their relationship is dwindled when reality is thrown in the mix. Laura cannot deny her heritage and religion, no matter how she rebels, and Djamel cannot escape his past which is written all over him. Mathilde's comes back to haunt Laura..."We are all alone." No matter what we may believe to be truth, in the end we are all alone in the results of our decisions.

Little Jerusalem is an amazing film about a family of Orthodox Jews living in Paris.The best reason to see this film is Fanny Valette. I think Fanny Valette may be one of the greatest actresses ever. Seeing her in this film was like seeing Brad Pitt for the first time in 'Cool World'. Although I hated, hated, hated 'Cool World', the second Brad Pitt appeared I knew he was going to be a major, major star. I felt the same way about Russell Crowe in 'Romper Stomper' as well. All I can say is brush up on your English Ms. Valette, because Hollywood is going to be pounding down your door any second now.