The Arnelo Affair (1947)

The story of a woman (Frances Gifford) whose marriage to a successful attorney (George Murphy) leaves her feeling under-appreciated. When she catches the eye of a client who owns an upscale night club (John Hodiak) and, as a means of getting to know her on more intimate terms, offers her a job to redo the interior decorating on his apartment, she eventually accepts, seemingly knowing what this would lead to. Married with a cute son (Dean Stockwell), she realizes she has everything to lose in the Arnelo Affair, especially when Tony Arnelo turns out to be a womanizer who is not above knocking off an interfering ex-lover, the evidence of which points to Gifford, thus adding considerably to her already heightened sense of anxiety, which seems to put her in a state of semi-shock. The affair goes on within her social circle which is captured in a great scene in Arnelo's night club after the murder, with Eve Arden, who is Gifford's friend, noticing something going on between Arnelo and Gifford. Murphy is pretty good as Gifford's husband who realizes she went astray due to his lack of attention. Gifford is worth seeing for her part as she gives in to her desire for Arnelo all the while racked with doubt and guilt and then fear of losing everything dear to her over doing so. And Hodiak turns in a great role as Arnelo, with exceeding smoothness and subtlety.

Though a remake of EVELYN PRENTICE, THE ARNELO AFFAIR is a perfect example of post-war films meant to reinforce the notion that a woman should be happy at home. If she strays too far from the nest, she will get embroiled in dangerous activities that threaten to destroy her marriage and put her in jail. Scare tactics to say the least, and people paid money to see it.This said, the picture does have its merits. For one thing, John Hodiak gives a good performance as the bad guy. And the music conveys the mood of the piece well. Overall, the story is mostly well paced, with a lot of silent pauses for proper dramatic effects. As for the troubled wife character. Frances Gifford helps us get a sense of the woman's internal state. When she reads her son's thoughts about her and breaks down, that's probably the emotional highlight of the film. Meanwhile, Eve Arden's character puts a bit of a satiric spin on the proceedings, helping it not to become too overwrought and to stay light in the right places. Ultimately, it's another spin on the old infidelity story, combining the gangster genre with the woman's melodrama.

The Arnelo Affair has John Hodiak in the title role of a nightclub owner with tax troubles getting an affair going with his lawyer's wife Frances Gifford.Frances is a woman with an itch and Hodiak is quite willing to scratch it. But as it turns out he's doing a bit of two timing himself on actress Joan Woodbury. Later on when Woodbury is murdered Hodiak is on the short list of Detective Warner Anderson suspects, but so is Gifford.This film is a great example of the Code strangling the creativity of film making. Today it would be quite explicitly filmed with proper sex scenes in their place. George Murphy played Gifford's husband and his is a strangely underwritten role. If I were doing the film and being that Hodiak is having tax troubles, when Murphy does find out there are hundreds of creative ways he could have done Hodiak good and proper.Eve Arden is in the film in an Eve Arden part. Though in this one she's sporting a hint of jealousy that Hodiak isn't giving her a tumble. That too should have been brought out more.The Arnelo Affair if someone decides to remake it has lots of room for improvement.

This was in my opinion an excellent classic... Pretty suspenseful and definitely entertaining.... Of course, what they considered an "affair" was definitely not an affair in the sense these days... I hope this classic appears on Video or DVD in the future